Ever stared at a job posting feeling confused by “CMA preferred” and “RMA accepted”? If you’re navigating the world of medical assisting, you’ve definitely been there. This certified vs registered medical assistant dilemma isn’t just alphabet soup—it’s a critical career decision that impacts where you can work, how much you might earn, and your long-term professional path. You deserve a clear, no-nonsense guide to cut through the confusion. This guide will break down the exact differences between these credentials, helping you make the smartest choice for your future with total confidence.
What is a Certified Medical Assistant (CMA)?
The Certified Medical Assistant (CMA) credential is administered by the American Association of Medical Assistants (AAMA). Think of the AAMA as the gold standard and most widely recognized certifying body for medical assistants in the United States. Founded in 1956, the AAMA has established a reputation for rigor and high standards.
Earning your CMA means you’ve passed a comprehensive exam that tests your knowledge across three critical domains: clinical, administrative, and general. This broad focus ensures CMAs are prepared to handle the diverse demands of a modern medical practice.
Pro Tip: The AAMA actively lobbies state and federal governments, which is a major reason why the CMA credential is so widely recognized and respected by legislators and large healthcare systems. This recognition often translates into more job opportunities, especially in hospital settings.
CMA (AAMA) Requirements
The path to becoming a CMA is strict but straightforward. You must complete a medical assisting program that holds accreditation from the Commission on Accreditation of Allied Health Education Programs (CAAHEP) or the Accrediting Bureau of Health Education Schools (ABHES).
Imagine you’ve just graduated from a CAAHEP-accredited program at your local community college. You’ve learned everything from patient intake and phlebotomy to electronic health records and medical billing. Now you’re eligible to sit for the CMA (AAMA) Certification Exam. You must pass this exam within 60 months of graduation. After certification, you need to recertify every 60 months by either retaking the exam or earning 60 continuing education credits.
What is a Registered Medical Assistant (RMA)?
The Registered Medical Assistant (RMA) credential is granted by American Medical Technologists (AMT). While also highly respected, the AMT takes a slightly different philosophical approach, often offering more flexible pathways to eligibility for their exam.
The RMA credential is also nationally recognized and signifies a medical assistant who has met rigorous standards of competence. AMT has been certifying health professionals since 1939, and the RMA credential is a trusted trademark in many clinics and physician offices across the country.
Clinical Pearl: The RMA path is often a great option for individuals who gained their skills through military medical training, apprenticeship programs, or who have years of verifiable on-the-job experience but graduated from a non-accredited program. It values practical, real-world expertise.
RMA (AMT) Requirements
AMT provides several routes to eligibility for the RMA exam, which is a key differentiator from the CMA path. You are eligible if you:
- Are a recent graduate of an accredited medical assisting program (similar to the CMA path).
- Have completed a formal medical services training program in the United States Armed Forces.
- Have been employed as a medical assistant for a minimum of five years out of the last seven years.
- Have an instructor-level status in an accredited medical assisting program.
This flexibility is the RMA’s hallmark. If you learned your skills on the job in a busy orthopedic clinic for several years but your original school closed or lost accreditation, the RMA path recognizes that valuable experience. To maintain your credential, you must recertify every three years by completing 30 continuing education credits.
Side-by-Side Comparison: CMA vs RMA Requirements
Let’s put these credentials head-to-head. This table breaks down the key differences you need to consider.
| Feature | CMA (AAMA) | RMA (AMT) | Winner / Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accrediting Body | American Association of Medical Assistants (AAMA) | American Medical Technologists (AMT) | Tie (both are national leaders) |
| Primary Eligibility | Must graduate from a CAAHEP/ABHES accredited program | Multiple paths (accredited program, military, work experience) | RMA (for flexibility) |
| Exam Focus | Broad cognitive exam covering clinical, admin, and general knowledge | Comprehensive exam covering clinical, admin, and general knowledge | Tie (both are rigorous) |
| Initial Exam Cost | ~$125-$250 (varies by membership/student status) | ~$125-$155 (varies by membership/student status) | RMA (slightly lower cost) |
| Recertification Cycle | Every 5 years (60 CEUs or retake exam) | Every 3 years (30 CEUs) | RMA (more frequent but smaller requirement) |
| General Recognition | Widely seen as the industry “gold standard,” especially in hospitals | Highly respected, very common in private practices and clinics | CMA (for broader institutional recognition) |
Key Takeaway: For those coming straight from an accredited program, the CMA path is the clear route. For those with non-traditional training or extensive experience, the RMA provides an accessible and respected alternative.
State Recognition and Employer Preferences
Here’s the thing: where you plan to work is arguably the most important factor in your decision. State regulations and employer preferences can vary dramatically, potentially making one credential significantly more valuable than the other depending on your location.
Some states, like California, Washington, and New Jersey, have specific Medical Assistant Practice Acts. These laws often outline the scope of practice for medical assistants and may explicitly name the CMA (AAMA) as a recognized credential.
For example, Washington state law allows CMAs to perform more advanced tasks, such as administering certain medications under physician supervision, because the CMA curriculum is specifically outlined and recognized in state statutes. In these states, having that CMA certification isn’t just a preference—it’s a legal gateway to a wider scope of practice.
How to Check Your State’s Requirements:
- Visit your state’s Department of Health or Medical Board website.
- Search for “Medical Assistant scope of practice” or “MA regulations.”
- Look for language that specifies certification requirements.
- Call potential employers and ask which credential they prefer for their new hires.
While employer preference is shifting toward the CMA, many private practices and smaller clinics value the experience and flexibility associated with the RMA. Research from healthcare staffing agencies consistently shows that CMAs often have a slight edge in salary and job openings, but RMAs remain in high demand across the country.
Career Growth and Salary Implications
Let’s talk numbers. Does one credential lead to a bigger paycheck? Research consistently shows that certified medical assistants—regardless of the specific credential—earn more than their non-certified counterparts.
When comparing CMA vs RMA salary, the difference is often modest but can be significant in certain markets. According to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and various salary surveys, CMAs may earn a slightly higher median wage. The primary reason for this is not necessarily the quality of education but market perception and how large healthcare systems structure their pay scales.
Think of it like brand-name versus generic medications. Both contain the same active ingredients (your clinical knowledge and skills), but the brand name (CMA) often has stronger marketing and greater recognition, leading to wider adoption in large hospital systems. These systems often have pay grades that specifically reward the CMA credential.
Key Takeaway: Certification is what unlocks higher pay. The choice between CMA and RMA offers a slight salary edge to the CMA in some markets, primarily due to institutional preference. The biggest financial mistake you can make is not getting certified at all.
Choosing Your Path: Factors to Consider
This is your career, so the decision is personal. Here’s how to cut through the noise and choose the right path for you. Ask yourself these four critical questions.
- Where do you want to live and work?
- Action Step: Research the top 5-10 employers in your target city. Are they large hospital networks (who often prefer CMAs) or smaller private practices (who may be more flexible with RMAs)? Check your state’s practice act.
- How did you complete your training?
- Scenario: If you’re about to graduate from a CAAHEP-accredited program, sitting for the CMA exam is the most direct and valuable path. If you’re a veteran with medical corps experience or have a non-accredited degree, the RMA path is your best and most realistic option.
- What’s your budget and learning style for continuing education?
- Consider: Can you commit to gathering 60 AAMA-approved credits over five years? Or does the more manageable, but more frequent, 30-credit cycle over three years with AMT fit your lifestyle better?
- What are your long-term career goals?
- Imagining Your Future: Do you aspire to work in a specialty hospital or move into a leadership role within a large health system? The CMA credential may provide a slight advantage. If your goal is to be the go-to expert in a thriving private clinic, either credential will serve you exceptionally well.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Common Mistake: Assuming one credential is “better” everywhere.
Why it’s a problem: This oversimplification can lead you to waste time or miss opportunities in your local market. An RMA in Texas might have zero trouble finding a great job, while a CMA in a state without specific recognition might not see the same “gold standard” benefits. Always research your local context!
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I hold both a CMA and an RMA at the same time? A: Yes, it is possible. If you meet the eligibility requirements for both exams, you can earn both credentials. Some medical assistants do this to maximize their job opportunities across different states and employer types.
Q: What happens if my certification lapses? Can I get it back? A: Both AAMA and AMT have grace periods and reinstatement policies. However, it’s a much more difficult and expensive process than simply maintaining your credential with continuing education. Stay on top of your renewal dates!
Q: Is the CMA exam really harder than the RMA exam? A: Both exams are rigorous and nationally recognized. There is no definitive evidence that one is inherently “harder” than the other. The difficulty often comes down to your specific program’s curriculum and your personal study habits. The CMA has a stricter initial eligibility path, which contributes to its reputation for difficulty.
Conclusion & Key Takeaways
Choosing between the CMA and RMA is a significant decision, but it’s also an empowering one. The core difference lies in the accrediting bodies: the CMA (AAMA) requires graduation from a nationally accredited program and is widely considered the industry gold standard, while the RMA (AMT) offers flexible eligibility paths, including military and work experience. Your best choice depends less on which is “better” overall and more on which is “better for you,” based on your location, training background, and career ambitions. Making an informed choice based on this research will set you on a path for success.
Have you decided between the CMA and RMA? Share what’s driving your decision in the comments below—your insight could help a fellow medical assistant!
Want more career-boosting tips and clinical insights delivered to your inbox? Subscribe to our weekly newsletter for exclusive CMA and RMA resources.
Know someone in your medical assistant program facing this exact choice? Share this comprehensive guide to help them make their decision with confidence